Resource Elements
- A practicing physical therapist changes her practice to embrace the neuroplastic understanding of persistent symptoms.
- Dr.s Hanscom, Merrill, Schubiner, and Kennedy were her mentors.
- Her discovery that the transition from standard practice to a neuroplastic perspective improved patient recovery.
- Her story of a patient with a knife in his chest for 8 years with no pain.
- Understanding neuroplastic symptoms is a game changer.
- Patients get better with fewer office visits.
- Understanding that pain is ok.
- Understanding noceboes and placebos.
- The 5 F’s that increase neuroplastic symptoms.
- The hot water analogy.
- Steps toward healing.
Nida’s audience seems to be primarily professionals but patients may gleam some gems from her experience. She began as a young athletic trainer then became a traveling physical therapist. After a high anxiety event, a friend recommended the Pain Reframe podcast which introduced her to newer neuroscience research concepts. Subsequently before the pandemic, she took a MINDBODY course by Merrill and Schubiner to understand how emotions and stress affect physical symptoms.
During the pandemic she had to teach physical therapy to patients mostly remotely, but they got better because of her new insights about the mechanism of pain! It was a game changer for her practice. Six years later she met Dr. Kennedy in the Kaiser system in Oregon and subsequently joined her at Resilience Healthcare. The concept she teaches now is ‘From Fear to Freedom’ concerning physical symptoms. The neuroscience of pain truly makes sense through her lens of 20 years practice.
Changing from a biomedical perspective to include the neuroscience of pain was a game changer. Pain intensity is related to the emotional aspect rather than the extent of tissue damage. She encountered an example where a man had a violent encounter but sought no medical care. Eight years later an Xray revealed a knife blade in his chest but he experienced no pain. She also cites a contrasting incident where a worker was in excruciating pain when a nail pierced his boot. It looked serious but the nail did not injure his foot. Damage does not equal pain.
She teaches the nocebo effect which involves a person’s reaction to opinions from others about possible practices or conditions that suggest illness or tissue damage. Abnormal conditions on X-rays and MRI images are usually normal changes like wrinkles, rather than evidence of injury. She also cites the placebo effect, and contagion theory that influence a person’s physical response to medical information and procedures, along with many examples.
Revealing concepts for her include the five F’s: fear, focus, flight, fix and frustration and their influence on the protective alarm system in their brain.
Another concept is the brain’s basic pattern of predictive coding, meaning it anticipates our experiences rather than reacting to them. She explains the concept that most pains are real but not dangerous.
She discusses the nervous system’s response to non-chronic and chronic pain, and the ‘pain alarm’.
She discusses steps toward healing: the FIT Criteria; Emotional Awareness and Expression Therapy; Visualizing; and Self-compassion.
Background [00:00]
Athletic trainer
Physical therapy degree
Traveling therapist
High anxiety level
Neuroplastic introduction [01:20]
Mind-body guy
Charlie Merril
Kaiser Oakland
Private cases – Kaiser’s system
Patients got better
Pain and Neuroplastic Concepts [03:32]
Understanding that pain is ok
Dr. Kennedy
Long-haul COVID – made sense
Tissue damage
Structural damage – fear freedom
Neuroscience of pain
Broader Perspective [06:03]
20 years
Chronic pain – huge
Biomedical perspective
Game changer
Produced in my brain
Pain intensity
Catastrophic injury
Amount of tissue damage
Emotional pain
Emotional pain triggers
Danger not damage
Selected Case Examples [09:10]
Knife in his chest
Eight years later
Nail in boot
Damage – not equate to – pain
Functional brain MRI
Emotional pain – physical pain
Eye-opening to me
Different concepts – pain
Broader Perspective than Physical Therapy [12:29]
Nocebo effect
Wear and tear
X-rays
Normal anomalies
Weak core
Bad posture
Best posture
Brain – protecting
Selected Case Examples [15:06]
Move around
Bulging discs
Nocebo effect
Danger over safety
Cause of pain
Plantar fasciitis
83 year old woman
Body awareness
Try – five minutes
Placebo effect
Feel better – knowing
Perfect shoe
More Examples [15:28]
Perfect shoe
Disc degeneration
Facet degeneration
Disc bulges
Fear approach
Contagion theory
Low back pain
Repetitive stress injury
Whiplash study
Whiplash – for decades
Chronic pain
Body is plastic
Ankle sprains
Rotator cuff surgery
Bone healing
Key insights for Me [25:43]
Schubiner’s work
Neuroplastic diagnoses
Five f’s
When – pain -comes
Fear study
Components of – pain
Movement assessments
Old model of pain
Kind of energy
Slow thing – waiting
More Insights [29:27]
Predictive coding
Learned neural pathway
Fear anticipation
Protective mechanisms
Lightness and ease
Push through
Analogy – hot water
Danger alarm signal
Visualize activity
Broader Perspective [32:47]
My goal
Get out of pain
Real – not dangerous
Whatever brings you joy
Dancing
Desensitize
Whatever- brain thinks it means
Book cure
Best predicator
Your Personal situation [35:48]
Need – more convincing
Okay if – don’t believe
Hardest patients
Neuroplastic – probably 90%
Movement assessment
Scared child
Research Insights [38:05]
Explain Pain – Moseley
Research on chronic pain
Normal regulated nervous system
Protect by pain
Hot Water Analogy
Acute Injury
Chronic Symptoms
The Pain Alarm [41:16]
Pain Alarm
Protect by Pain Alarm
New ‘Protect by Pain Alarm’
Flare Up
Crash Out
Over Sensitized Alarm
Flare Up
Steps Toward Healing [41:53]
General Steps
FIT Criteria
Dive In
Expressive Writing
EAE Therapy
Scared Child
Visualizing
Self-Compassion
Views: 16

